Come Judge the 3 final drawings for my DBZ contest

These are the finalists to my contest. if you wanna help judge it would be awesome .Chose over all witch 1 you like best if you can explain why it would be great but you dont have to. Thanks Union

#1[img][/img]

#2[img][/img]

#3[img][/img]

This is good till tomorrow

Number 1: this drawing is very good some flaws but, the facial shading is on point with goku. i feel like its soo much with vegeta it makes the right side of his face look square ish. Also the shading on the clothes is half ass but, the detail on vegeta's arm, his armor, all awesome....


Number 2: i like the simplicity in the nice soft colors looks good, not as much detail as 1, but just means less things you can mess up on.......


Number 3: BOO isn't the easiest to draw bc of all the pink shading you gotta do, and how shiny the motherfucker always is but, on the bright side very soft color which i like. The person doesn't over due the the drawing with immense colors on.


so honestly it can go either way number 1 or 3

Damm. Nice imput. But if you have to go with just 1 witch 1?

Damn this is hard... First one is perfect except for Vegeta's face, Second one is perfect except for the coloring, Third one is perfect but is simpler than the previous two...

I vote #3
#1 as a close 2nd place

#3 hit the ball out of the park. Proportions are dead on, shading is killer and they could have filled the background with a bunch of bullshit but they didnt. They let the eye focus on the character, and instead of seeing how well they shaded that tree in the background you can see all the details in the skin tones and I think that really puts it above the rest.

#1 has vegeta's head all effed up, they have a problem with proportions(also notice goku's fingers)

#2 looks like they took some time on it but they could have probably spent some more time shading and whatnot.

How old are all these contestants? That would also change my opinion on some of them and to forgive some of the flaws. But unless #1 is in middle school they need to pay more attention in art class. Getting proportions right is the first step to making an awesome drawing.

KraZe wrote:

Damn this is hard... First one is perfect except for Vegeta's face, Second one is perfect except for the coloring, Third one is perfect but is simpler than the previous two...

I vote #3
#1 as a close 2nd place

ima have to agree krazeeee

Steinkrunk wrote:

#3 hit the ball out of the park. Proportions are dead on, shading is killer and they could have filled the background with a bunch of bullshit but they didnt. They let the eye focus on the character, and instead of seeing how well they shaded that tree in the background you can see all the details in the skin tones and I think that really puts it above the rest.

#1 has vegeta's head all effed up, they have a problem with proportions(also notice goku's fingers)

#2 looks like they took some time on it but they could have probably spent some more time shading and whatnot.

How old are all these contestants? That would also change my opinion on some of them and to forgive some of the flaws. But unless #1 is in middle school they need to pay more attention in art class. Getting proportions right is the first step to making an awesome drawing.

i mean the person might just practice drawing goku more then vegeta bc goku's face is perfect or atleast close too it there is a lil dip in the cheek line going to his jaw! Still better then what i can draw!

LOL ill tell u guys age of ppl who did these.

When its over tonight at midnight

Ppl on my Facebook are also judging. I'm counting all votes

Well #3 was the winner. Done by my sister. She's 22.
#1 & #2 was a tie.
#2 was made by my sisters husband he's 26
#1 was made by me. It was done in Crayola markers so mistakes couldn't be reversed. You guys are tough judge's but I like it.

Woooaaahh haha YOU made #1!? It was really good! and your sister has talent!

Yeah thanks. I honestly haven't done anything since 2007 or 8.. She does i tought her some. all she needs is to expand to more than just color pencil. I can do much better in a canvas with acrylic paint or water colors. My next goal is to teach her that

Well i'm a little late, but man #1 was great except for Vegeta's face. If that had been done right i'd pick that easily. I like the art of #2, but the coloring is a little dull. #3 looks the best overall.

Thanks man. I tried but cheap crayola markers are no good. Lost my color pensils since I haven't use them. But there will be more competitions. Maybe next time union can join.

#2 is awesome other people critisized the colours but i like just that it doesnt slap you with them. Allows to focus more on the motive and execution. Which is near to perfection to me. So my vote would have been #2

The best advice I can give you is use a light pencil to do a "rough draft", then you can erase if you make mistakes or whatnot and you won't be able to see it under the marker. That said your family is pretty talented!! Lol I remember when I was in highschool I used to draw all the time, I had a book I kept as a portfolio that had everything from landscapes to anime characters to car drawings. I had a lot of time in that book and then someone stole it and that pretty much ended my artistic phase.

Sorry if you thought my creative criticism was alittle rough but when I was in high school I was the best in my class and I would always get pissed when my classmates would praise a piece that even I saw flaws in. I could only count on the teacher to give me an honest opinion and I was thankful for it. It helps you figure out what you need to work on and that helped me get better and better.

All that being said I haven't really drawn since highschool and I suck now lol. I probably couldn't come close to any of those drawings lol.

@steinkrunk LOL I was the same way in high-school. I like the criticism will make me do better next time. This 1 I rushed and didn't have the right tools. Used Crayola markers and to make it worse I used a cheap glossy paper I got from Office Depot so the paint would not stick. Look at the fingers ,paint kinda runny. Next time ill do a better job and wont rush it. Cant let my little sister beat me.

My pick would be #3.

Great job on proportions, shading, and the line work is VERY clean.